In this picture you can see some color on the lid which is not visible in the first picture. To achieve that add some taupy color to your crease and create a slanted 'V' shape at the outer corner.
Use Mabelline color tatoo in "Bad to the bronze"
or Nyx Jumbo Eye Pencil in "Iced mocha" [Read review here]
I love this look of hers! What about you?